Home › Structure · Conflicts
Structure · Conflicts

One counterparty for the land and the loan sounds simple. Until the default.

A provider offers to buy your land and make the leasehold construction loan, sometimes as one package to its investors. One party, one closing, one set of documents. It is efficient on the way in. It is the wrong structure to be in on the way out.

When the lessor is the lender, every protection in the lease is owed to the same party it protects against.
A ground lease is financeable because the leasehold lender has rights against the landlord: notice of default, time to cure, a new lease if the old one is terminated. When the landlord and the lender are the same party, those rights are owed to itself. The checks disappear, and the party holding the fee, the rent and the loan gets to choose how a default ends.
Why it gets offered

The package is easier to sell. That is the provider’s problem, not yours.

The offer usually comes with a good story. One party underwrites the whole project. One set of documents. No arguing between a landlord and a bank over cure periods and casualty proceeds. A faster close.

Some of that is real. But look at why the provider wants it. A land position pays a fixed rent. A construction loan pays a floating rate, origination fees and often exit fees. Putting both in one package lets a provider show its own investors a higher day-one return than the land alone would produce. The loan is doing the work the land cannot.

That is a reasonable business for the provider. It is not a reason for you to give up the separation that protects your building. Ask what the land offer looks like without the loan. If it disappears, you learned what the offer was really about.

Why the separation matters

Foreclosure is a sale. Termination is a forfeiture.

In a normal structure, if you default on the leasehold loan, the lender forecloses on the leasehold. It sells the building, or takes it and keeps the lease in place. The ground lease survives. The landlord keeps getting rent. If the sale brings more than the debt, the surplus goes to you.

A lease termination works differently. The leasehold ends, and the building passes to the fee owner. There is no sale and no surplus. That is why leasehold lenders insist the lease cannot be terminated without notice to them, a chance to cure, and the right to a new lease. Those rules exist to make sure a loan problem never turns into a forfeiture of the building.

Now put one party in both seats. A loan default triggers a lease default, often by an express cross-default. The party in both seats now has two paths: foreclose the loan and sell, or terminate the lease and keep the building. The second path can be worth more to it. Nothing independent stands in the way.

At a loan default Lessor is also the lender Independent leasehold lender
Notice and cure rightsOwed to itselfOwed to a separate party with its own money at risk
New lease after terminationOwed to itselfEnforceable by the lender against the landlord
How it endsThe same party picks foreclosure or terminationForeclosure or workout; the lease stays in place
Surplus valueCan be forfeited if the lease is terminatedGoes to the borrower after a sale
Refinancing laterOften needs the same party’s consent or carries its exit feesAny lender the lease allows, on objective criteria
The quieter problems

Sizing, refinancing and who the investors are.

Loan sizing. A provider that earns on both pieces can stretch the loan to make the package work. Look at the leasehold coverage at the rate floor, not at the projected rate. If the building barely covers the loan after ground rent, the package was built for the provider’s raise, not for your project.

Refinancing. Construction loans are meant to be refinanced. A bundled loan can carry exit fees, minimum interest, or consent rights that make a third-party refinance slow or expensive, sometimes waived only if the provider’s own affiliate does the refinance.

Agency take-out. Agency and many private leasehold lenders look for a ground lessor that is independent of the borrower and a lease with full mortgagee protections. A package designed around one party can need rework before a permanent lender will lend behind it. See what leasehold lenders require.

Our rule

We never lend on the leasehold. We arrange it.

We buy the land and hold it. We do not make leasehold loans, construction or permanent, short or long, with or without guaranties. That is not a pricing choice. It is the whole point of the structure: our lease is drafted so an independent leasehold lender can lend behind it with notice, cure, new-lease rights and no termination for incurable defaults.

We arrange the leasehold loan with an independent lender. Our fee for that is 1% of the loan, earned only at the closing of that financing. If the loan does not close, it is not earned. More on the lender side in leasehold mortgage financing.

If someone offers both

Six questions to ask before you accept.

1. Does any default under the loan let you terminate the ground lease? Show me the cross-default language.

2. Will the lease carry full leasehold mortgagee protections that run to any future lender, including a refinance lender, and to anyone you sell the loan to?

3. On a default, do you commit to foreclose rather than terminate, and does any surplus come to me?

4. Can I refinance the loan with an unrelated lender without your consent, exit fee or minimum interest?

5. Is the loan sized independently, and what is the leasehold coverage at the rate floor after ground rent?

6. Are the fee and the loan held by different entities with different investors, and who decides at a default?

Clear, written answers to all six make the package safer. Vague answers tell you what you need to know.

For 1031 investors

Every ground lease we write creates two things you can buy.

The land, on a 99-year lease: nothing to manage, senior to the building’s lender, low yield because the buyer is buying the right to not pay the tax. The building above it: higher yield, paid monthly, depreciable. Both are replacement property. Both close on a date we control, which is the part that matters on day 140.

1031 Solutions

Working with an intermediary? The standby sheet for line 3 of the identification form.

Questions, answered

FAQ.

Is it ever fine for the ground lessor to make the leasehold loan?

It can be survivable if the lease carries full leasehold mortgagee protections for any future lender, there is no cross-default that lets a loan default terminate the lease, and you can refinance away freely. Most bundled offers do not give all three. Separation is cleaner.

Why does foreclosure versus termination matter so much?

Foreclosure sells the leasehold and keeps the lease alive, and any surplus over the debt goes to the borrower. Termination ends the leasehold and the building passes to the fee owner, with no sale and no surplus.

Will Valor make my leasehold construction loan?

No. We never lend on the leasehold. We buy the land and arrange the leasehold loan with an independent lender, for a 1 percent fee earned only at the closing of that loan.

Why would a provider want to do both?

It is one more source of fees and yield, and a combined package can be easier to sell to its own investors. That is the provider's reason, not yours. Ask the six questions on this page.

Does a permanent lender care who the ground lessor is?

Yes. Agency and many private leasehold lenders look for a ground lessor that is not a borrower affiliate and a lease with full mortgagee protections. A lease designed around one party in both seats can need rework before a permanent lender will lend.

Get your number

Got an offer for both? Send it before you sign.

The term sheet for the land and the term sheet for the loan. We will show you where the default path runs and what an independent leasehold lender would need.

No NDA and no client names needed. These four facts are enough for a real number.

Or email [email protected].