There is no single right answer: leasing keeps the land and pays income for decades, while selling turns it into mission capital today — surveys of faith-based housing deals show congregations split roughly evenly between the two, on lease terms of 55 to 99 years. The real questions are what rent the deal can actually pay (there is a framework, below), and the two tax traps — property-tax exemption loss on leased portions and unrelated business income rules — that you must clear before signing anything.
| Ground lease | Sell | Donate to a land trust | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you give up | Possession for 55–99 years — a long landlord role, in exchange for income over time and the parcel back at the end. | The land, permanently — one closing, one check, and the capital is yours today. | The land and the economics, permanently. |
| What you get | Escalating ground rent for the full term, plus the improved parcel back at expiry. | Today's land value, once. What the site becomes after that is the buyer's story. | Mission permanence — housing stewarded by the trust for good. |
| Income to the congregation | A contractual rent check, typically escalating ~2% a year, that outlives the current vestry. | None after closing — the proceeds become an investment-committee problem. | None, or nominal — $1 a year is common. |
| Who holds the land in 75 years | You do. The lease ends and the parcel — improvements included — reverts to the church. | Whoever the buyer eventually sold it to. | The land trust, permanently. |
| Mission control | Strong — use and affordability terms are written into your lease. | Only whatever deed restrictions you negotiated at closing. | Strongest — permanent stewardship is the whole point of a CLT. |
| Best when | You want both — income along the way and the land back at the end. | You need capital now and are finished with the site. | The housing is the mission and the economics genuinely don't matter. |
One distinction before you negotiate: a community land trust lease and a market ground lease are different instruments. The CLT is a steward — typically a resale-restricted homeownership model where the trust holds the land permanently. An institutional ground lease is a financing structure for a rental project — it exists so the developer's lender can underwrite the deal. This page is about the second; the donate path is real, but it belongs in a different conversation. How the rental structure works from the developer's side: affordable housing on a ground lease.
The developer's lender underwrites your ground rent as an operating expense of the project, so the ceiling on what any developer can pay is set by the project's stabilized net operating income — not by what the parcel would fetch as a lot, and not by what the congregation hopes. Mission-neutral leases typically size at 10–25% of stabilized NOI with strong coverage, escalating around 2% annually — on fully market deals ground rent runs to roughly 25% of NOI (30% is the ceiling), covered 3–4x by project income. Mission-priced leases run all the way down to $1 a year, where the congregation's goal is the housing, not the income. Both are legitimate. The mistake is not knowing which deal you are doing before you negotiate. How the income stream itself is valued: ground lease cap rates · how these leases are sized on rental projects: multifamily ground leases.
Neither trap should kill a good deal — but both have surprised congregations that discovered them after signing. Clear them first, in writing, with counsel who has done faith-based housing work.
| The trap | How congregations clear it | |
|---|---|---|
| Property-tax exemption | Many states reduce or revoke a religious property-tax exemption on portions leased for non-exempt use. Surprise assessments on newly leased church land are a documented pattern, not a hypothetical — and they land on the church as fee owner. | Model the carry before committing. Check whether your state exempts affordable housing on its own footing, and write who bears any assessment into the lease — never leave it to be discovered after closing. |
| Unrelated business income (UBIT) | Ground-lease income is generally exempt from unrelated business income tax only when the leased property is debt-free on the church's side. Debt on the parcel can convert clean, exempt rent into taxable income. | Keep the church's side of the parcel unlevered. The developer's own construction loan is fine — it sits on the leasehold, not on the church — so long as the church is not obligated on it in any way. |
Both are counsel questions — budget for them. A few thousand dollars of tax and real estate counsel before the letter of intent is the cheapest insurance in the whole transaction.
No lender funds a 40-year affordable project on land it could lose to a landlord dispute. A financeable ground lease means the church concedes a standard set of lender protections — none of them exotic, all of them non-negotiable in practice. Knowing the list going in makes the church a credible counterparty instead of a six-month delay.
| What it means | Why the lender requires it | |
|---|---|---|
| Notice and cure rights | The lender is notified of any developer default under the lease and gets time to cure it before the church can act. | Long-dated money cannot be wiped out by a missed notice. |
| No termination without consent | The church cannot end the lease over the lender's objection while the loan is outstanding. | Termination extinguishes the collateral entirely. |
| New-lease rights | If the lender forecloses on the leasehold, the church signs a replacement lease with the lender or its buyer on the same terms. | It preserves the collateral through a developer failure — and keeps the church's rent flowing. |
| Recognition of the lender | The church formally acknowledges the leasehold mortgage and agrees to deal with the lender as the lease contemplates. | It is what makes the whole package financeable on day one. |
| A 55-to-99-year term | The tax rules behind the developer's credits set a floor of only about 30 years — but the market convention for financeable affordable deals is 55 to 99 years, and agency guides require the lease to run well past loan maturity. | The loan needs collateral with a term far longer than itself. How the developer's tax-credit deal works: LIHTC on a ground lease. |
And your own approvals: expect denominational or hierarchical consent for any long-term disposition of church land — most polities treat a 75-year lease like a sale for approval purposes — so build that calendar into the deal early. NYC congregations working under the city's new housing incentives have an additional local playbook: 485-x and ground leases in NYC.
What actually comes back at lease end is the improved parcel — land plus whatever stands on it — in the condition and restriction state the lease and the recorded documents dictate. Read that part twice: under some affordable programs the recorded affordability restrictions are permanent and survive on your land after the lease ends. For many congregations, permanently affordable housing on church land is precisely the point — but it should be a decision the vestry makes with open eyes, not a discovery in year 74.
And the end arrives sooner than the term suggests: a developer refinancing in year 40 of a 75-year lease will need a term extension to make the new loan work, so plan the extension mechanics up front — pre-agreed extension options at ascertainable rent keep the project financeable for decades and spare both sides a cliff-edge renegotiation. A long ground lease is not a set-and-forget document; it is a relationship, and the congregations that fare best write the renewal road map into the lease on day one.
Both are faithful answers, and faith-based deals split roughly evenly between them. Leasing fits a congregation that wants to keep the land and an income stream that outlives the current leadership: the lease pays escalating rent for 55 to 99 years and then the improved parcel reverts to the church. Selling fits a congregation that needs capital now to fund its mission and is ready to hand the site to the developer outright. The mistake is defaulting into one without pricing both, and without clearing the property-tax and UBIT questions first.
The ceiling is set by the project's stabilized net operating income, because the developer's lender underwrites ground rent as an operating expense. Mission-neutral leases typically size at 10 to 25 percent of stabilized NOI with strong coverage, escalating around 2 percent a year; the capitalized value of that stream generally lands near the land's appraised value. Mission-priced leases run all the way down to one dollar a year, where the congregation's goal is the housing rather than the income. Decide which deal you are doing before you negotiate, and make a below-market rent an explicit contribution, not an accident.
It can, on the leased portions. Many states reduce or revoke a religious property-tax exemption where church land is leased for non-exempt use, and surprise assessments on newly leased parcels are a documented pattern. Some states separately exempt affordable housing, which can preserve the result under a different statute. Model the carry before committing, write into the lease who bears any assessment, and treat the question as a counsel item with a budget line, not an afterthought.
Generally no. Rent from real property is generally excluded from unrelated business income tax, so ground-lease income is typically exempt, but the key condition is that the leased property is debt-free on the church's side. Debt on the parcel can convert exempt rent into taxable income. The developer's own construction loan does not cause the problem, because it sits on the leasehold rather than on the church, as long as the church is not obligated on it. Confirm the structure with tax counsel before signing.
Six questions cover most of it. Who is your lender, and have they financed affordable projects on leased land before? What is the project's stabilized NOI, and how many times over does it cover our ground rent? What restrictions will be recorded against our land, and do they survive the lease? Who pays if the leased portion loses its property-tax exemption? What happens to our rent and our land if the project fails and the lender forecloses on the leasehold? And what approvals does our own denomination require for a disposition this long? A developer with crisp answers to all six is a counterparty; one without them is a risk.
Whether you are the congregation weighing a developer's offer or the developer structuring the deal — send the parcel address, the project's expected stabilized NOI, and where the conversation stands. We return an indicative land value and a ground-rent framework fast, as principal or arranged capital, so the vestry can decide between a real number and a real number.
Email us the deal